Tanzer on Spain
Tanzer on Spain
Ver mensaje de WaltZalenskiStephen the ";other"; American wine critic, covered Spain in his latest newsletter. Here are a few selected exerpts from his overview:
";One of the stiffest challenges facing Spanish producers is the difficulty of getting their wines from the bodega to the consumer without cooking them. Much of Spain is extremely hot for half of the year, and few importers have mastered the art of getting their wines from their clients to the coast without exposure to heat. Spanish truck drivers, it seems, are virtually required by law to break for lunch while their wines simmer in the afternoon sun.";
";Critics of New Wave Spanish wines bemoan the fact that much of today’s market has lost interest in the best old-guard producers of Spain, particularly of Rioja....But as with topnotch older Bordeaux, the finest Riojas of yesteryear were always the exceptions, and there were far too many lean, green, dried-out or downright dirty wines released during the same decades. Diehard fans of traditional Spanish wines who bemoan the new style and valorize the old are often talking about the wines of their memory, which have a tendency to get better every day.";
";Are Spain’s New Wave wines balanced, and will they age? Sure, they’re darker, richer, riper and more extracted. A lot of them are also hot, shapeless, and lacking in freshness. But the best of them are also reasonably balanced and loaded with ripe fruit. It’s tempting to compare some of Spain’s superrich new bottlings to high-octane shirazes from Australia, but I find that the better Spanish wines have more Old World savoir-faire and suaver textures. They are also far less likely to come across as overly manipulated.";
Re: Tanzer on Spain
Ver mensaje de WaltZalenskiDunno much about #2, and #3 is yet to pass the test of time, but #1 reads exactly like the cheap lowblow they’re needing (VERY badly) right now.
As always, in typical Spanish fashion, we invest $100,000,000 in a sophisticated piece of machinery and then it explodes under our noses because some cheap ******** saved $2 on batteries...
Good for Tanzer. I’m sure some indignant red noses will react to this just in order to prove him wrong (ex post facto)...
Return of the Prodigal Son
Ver mensaje de GastronautaHi there Gastro fortunately you are not missing!!! ;)))
Let me say that the comment on cooking wines is a little bit silly... Mmmm, is strange that Tanzer gave any credit to such a ridiculous question.
About the rest .... well I can agree with what Tanzer says..... in fact Tanzer is one I trust far more than Parker....
Cheers!
Re: Tanzer on Spain
Ver mensaje de GastronautaIt is certainly worth a word of caution to always worry about important details like this. My personal view is that there is a lot of cooked wine most everywhere - for example in restaurant ";cellars"; - and not just Spanish wine.
Tanzer wrote about this in the context of wines imported to the US. But if it is a pervasive problem with Spanish wine it should be evident in the domestic market as well. Indeed, the problem could be worse in the domestic market. I think all serious importers use ";refers"; to ship the wine overseas. If the problem is ground transportation in Spain, it may well be that wines in the domestic market spend just as much time or more on those hot trucks. Do people think that baked wine is a big problem in Spain?
Re: Return of the Prodigal Son
Ver mensaje de Paco HigónYes, Ernesto - don’t be a stranger here
Re: Tanzer on Spain
Ver mensaje de WaltZalenskiNope, at least no more that foreign wines.... for instance I just remember a letter from Aalto Cellar telling me that on summer they do not send wine..... and, in fact, best producers avoid sending wine inthe hottest part of summer
In general the conditions of transport are not worse than in the rest of the world....at least, as far as I know ....
Re: Tanzer on Spain
Ver mensaje de Paco HigónI think Tanzer accepts and review Spanish wines that are not imported. Presumably, such wines are shipped in small packages by mail or FedEx-type delivery services (not by the large refrigerated shipping containers used by reputable importers). I wonder if this contributes to Tanzer’s view that the problem is worse for Spanish wine.